Client wants to delete Google My Business Due to Bad Review

[AL123al]

My client has received a bad review on Google and although has other good ones, wants to delete the current Google My Business page and open a new one. I disagree with this strategy but need some evidence to back it up. They are ranking well and so I don't want to upset the cart. I need reasons not to in terms of potentially harming rankings. Am I right that this could impact?

[MarketAPeel]

@al123al As someone who has worked in the online review world - I have the script for the "Cancel it all because I got a bad review"

Bad reviews are a good thing because:

1. They add credibility to all your reviews b/c the profile won't look fake
2. They give you a chance to tell your side of the story and showcase your commitment to your customers
3. They signal to the wrong potential customer who would give you a headache, that you aren't the right person
4. They signal to the right potential customer that you are the right person b/c they disagree with the reasoning
5. They fill out the story and show the market what you do when things go wrong

People want to know what a business will do when things aren't perfect - We know that things won't always go right and a bad review gives you the opportunity to say, "Yes, this wasn't perfect but this is how I stepped up to fix the problem, it's too bad that the customer thought I provided X when I actually do Y."

Bad reviews are the result of expectations not being met, manage the expectation and you may not get the sale, but you won't end up with a Bad Review either.

For more about why a bad review is a good thing - https://www.marketapeel.agency/post/bad-reviews-are-a-good-thing

[Njnbiure45r4]

You can delete it from your GMB data. Try to remove all the data of the business and details. just like I did for Bud apk program.

[MiriamEllis]

Thanks, John! Kind of you to say. Reviews happen to be my favorite aspect of Local.

[JohnMckillip375]

This is for real ....Miriam definitely you are rockstar

[mostcg]

In addition to the other recommendations, I would advise you to have the business owner leave a response to the bad review.

1. It shows that the business is active.

2. If the customers that left the review happens to be real, it could potentially mend that relationship.

3. It could lessen the concerns of any potential customers who see the bad review and are put off by it.

-Andrew

[AL123al]

Thanks to all.

[MiriamEllis]

Great topic, AL123al!

I agree with all of the posters who are stating that your client's approach isn't practical. I have a couple of resources I'd recommend you share with the client that should get him up-to-speed on this topic.

1. First, show the client this article on the realities of review spam. It's real, and there are actions you can take. It takes persistence sometimes, but you've got to be hearty in business:

https://a-moz.groupbuyseo.org/blog/review-spam

2. Then, show him this second article which details how to handle all types of reviews, from 1-star disasters, to 5-star treasures, to spam:

https://a-moz.groupbuyseo.org/blog/mastering-owner-response-quintet-google-my-business-reviews

If you get get the client to sit tight and read through both of those, he should walk away with a completely different (and much better) perspective on dealing with the reality of reviews.

End of the day, attempting to delete a GMB listing is not an answer. The listing could simply come back again, and your client's reputation will follow him wherever he goes. Much better to get the necessary education to deal with all forms of reviews, and move forward confidently.

[MiriamEllis]

LOL. Funny analogy, EGOL.

[AL123al]

The client has really pushed his clients to write a Google review so think we are going to keep the GMB and push the bad review low. The review was a spam review from a "Local Guide" as the client has not got a record of this person's interaction with the company i.e. he never used their services. The client has flagged it with Google but nothing has been done.

Thanks

[LindsayE]

Not a good idea, I know it's hard to explain these types of things from an SEO point of view that the customer understands. You're going to lose all your good reviews that the business has gained. I'm also not sure if you're able to just create a new GMB once you mark the current one permanently closed without changing the NAP. I agree with SEOman10, work on getting some new positive reviews going.

Also, if the review was not left by a real customer can't you report it to Google or no?

[EGOL]

Every business will get a few bad reviews.  The Pope could be selling Bibles and get bad reviews from cranky customers or customers who blame the Pope when the package is lost on the mail.

The client probably has a nice business, is perfectly honest and does an excellent job.  Don't worry about one review.

[Joe_Stoffel]

You're welcome!

[Roman-Delcarmen]

I had to deal with several cases like this one in the past, one technique that got me good results was pretty simple.

I created an email campaign with the most trusted clients of my client, requesting their opinion on Google, was pretty successful so then, I even integrated Trustpilot in the equation.

1. Buy some good looking email template
2. Take your time to create a good content for the email
3. _You could even offer some kind of PR service _
4. Launch the campaign and remember is a game of numbers if you have a total 5 reviews in your site and you have a score of 3 get 1 point up will take you 5 new reviews with 5 stars

[AL123al]

Thanks Joe for your insight.

[Joe_Stoffel]

Hi there,

To be honest, I don't even think this is an option for them. Deleting/removing the Google My Business account does not actually delete the page, it just removes you as the manager/owner but that will still be returned in local search results (see this Google Help Forum Post).

The only way I've seen people have any success with this was to mark the location as permanently closed (which I would not recommend here) or to contact Google Business support and ask them to delete the listing. The problem here is I don't think the Google Business support team is going to delete this listing for bad reviews, they are likely going to suggest (as SEOman suggested) you focus on building up positive reviews and responding to the negative reviews currently associated with the page.

[AL123al]

Thanks. Yes my concern is that the person who left the bad review (and wasn't a real customer) would come back to the new GMB and do it all again.

[seoman10]

I'm not too sure whether it's a ranking factor or not, there are varying opinions.  I would say it's risky.

Additionally, I don't see what there is to be gained by deleting and recreating a profile that could just get another bad review, Also the person that gave you that bad review can come and leave another one!

I would work with some good customers and ask them to do reviews. Far more productive than trying to hide hide mistakes and Google will love good reviews to.

Explain to your client that resources are better spend on creating some new reviews and if you get enough good ones you can outweigh the bad ones to a large degree.  Take a look around, you will see there is plenty of excellent brands that get bad reviews from time to time.