• majorAlexa

        See all notifications

        Skip to content
        Moz logo Menu open Menu close
        • Products
          • Moz Pro
          • Moz Pro Home
          • Moz Local
          • Moz Local Home
          • STAT
          • Moz API
          • Moz API Home
          • Compare SEO Products
          • Moz Data
        • Free SEO Tools
          • Domain Analysis
          • Keyword Explorer
          • Link Explorer
          • Competitive Research
          • MozBar
          • More Free SEO Tools
        • Learn SEO
          • Beginner's Guide to SEO
          • SEO Learning Center
          • Moz Academy
          • MozCon
          • Webinars, Whitepapers, & Guides
        • Blog
        • Why Moz
          • Digital Marketers
          • Agency Solutions
          • Enterprise Solutions
          • Small Business Solutions
          • The Moz Story
          • New Releases
        • Log in
        • Log out
        • Products
          • Moz Pro

            Your all-in-one suite of SEO essentials.

          • Moz Local

            Raise your local SEO visibility with complete local SEO management.

          • STAT

            SERP tracking and analytics for enterprise SEO experts.

          • Moz API

            Power your SEO with our index of over 44 trillion links.

          • Compare SEO Products

            See which Moz SEO solution best meets your business needs.

          • Moz Data

            Power your SEO strategy & AI models with custom data solutions.

          Let your business shine with Listings AI
          Moz Local

          Let your business shine with Listings AI

          Learn more
        • Free SEO Tools
          • Domain Analysis

            Get top competitive SEO metrics like DA, top pages and more.

          • Keyword Explorer

            Find traffic-driving keywords with our 1.25 billion+ keyword index.

          • Link Explorer

            Explore over 40 trillion links for powerful backlink data.

          • Competitive Research

            Uncover valuable insights on your organic search competitors.

          • MozBar

            See top SEO metrics for free as you browse the web.

          • More Free SEO Tools

            Explore all the free SEO tools Moz has to offer.

          NEW Keyword Suggestions by Topic
          Moz Pro

          NEW Keyword Suggestions by Topic

          Learn more
        • Learn SEO
          • Beginner's Guide to SEO

            The #1 most popular introduction to SEO, trusted by millions.

          • SEO Learning Center

            Broaden your knowledge with SEO resources for all skill levels.

          • On-Demand Webinars

            Learn modern SEO best practices from industry experts.

          • How-To Guides

            Step-by-step guides to search success from the authority on SEO.

          • Moz Academy

            Upskill and get certified with on-demand courses & certifications.

          • MozCon

            Save on Early Bird tickets and join us in London or New York City

          Unlock flexible pricing & new endpoints
          Moz API

          Unlock flexible pricing & new endpoints

          Find your plan
        • Blog
        • Why Moz
          • Digital Marketers

            Simplify SEO tasks to save time and grow your traffic.

          • Small Business Solutions

            Uncover insights to make smarter marketing decisions in less time.

          • Agency Solutions

            Earn & keep valuable clients with unparalleled data & insights.

          • Enterprise Solutions

            Gain a competitive edge in the ever-changing world of search.

          • The Moz Story

            Moz was the first & remains the most trusted SEO company.

          • New Releases

            Get the scoop on the latest and greatest from Moz.

          Surface actionable competitive intel
          New Feature

          Surface actionable competitive intel

          Learn More
        • Log in
          • Moz Pro
          • Moz Local
          • Moz Local Dashboard
          • Moz API
          • Moz API Dashboard
          • Moz Academy
        • Avatar
          • Moz Home
          • Notifications
          • Account & Billing
          • Manage Users
          • Community Profile
          • My Q&A
          • My Videos
          • Log Out

        The Moz Q&A Forum

        • Forum
        • Questions
        • My Q&A
        • Users
        • Ask the Community

        Welcome to the Q&A Forum

        Browse the forum for helpful insights and fresh discussions about all things SEO.

        1. Home
        2. SEO Tactics
        3. Intermediate & Advanced SEO
        4. Canonical URLs and Sitemaps

        Moz Q&A is closed.

        After more than 13 years, and tens of thousands of questions, Moz Q&A closed on 12th December 2024. Whilst we’re not completely removing the content - many posts will still be possible to view - we have locked both new posts and new replies. More details here.

        Canonical URLs and Sitemaps

        Intermediate & Advanced SEO
        3
        7
        14554
        Loading More Posts
        • Watching

          Notify me of new replies.
          Show question in unread.

        • Not Watching

          Do not notify me of new replies.
          Show question in unread if category is not ignored.

        • Ignoring

          Do not notify me of new replies.
          Do not show question in unread.

        • Oldest to Newest
        • Newest to Oldest
        • Most Votes
        Reply
        • Reply as question
        Locked
        This topic has been deleted. Only users with question management privileges can see it.
        • 379seo
          379seo last edited by

          We are using canonical link tags for product pages in a scenario where the URLs on the site contain category names, and the canonical URL points to a URL which does not contain the category names.  So, the product page on the site is like www.example.com/clothes/skirts/skater-skirt-12345, and also like www.example.com/sale/clearance/skater-skirt-12345 in another category.  And on both of these pages, the canonical link tag references a 3rd URL like www.example.com/skater-skirt-12345.  This 3rd URL, used in the canonical link tag is a valid page, and displays the same content as the other two versions, but there are no actual links to this generic version anywhere on the site (nor external).

          Questions:

          1. Does the generic URL referenced in the canonical link also need to be included as on-page links somewhere in the crawled navigation of the site, or is it okay to be just a valid URL not linked anywhere except for the canonical tags?

          2. In our sitemap, is it okay to reference the non-canonical URLs, or does the sitemap have to reference only the canonical URL?  In our case, the sitemap points to yet a 3rd variation of the URL, like www.example.com/product.jsp?productID=12345.  This page retrieves the same content as the others, and includes a canonical link tag back to www.example.com/skater-skirt-12345.  Is this a valid approach, or should we revise the sitemap to point to either the category-specific links or the canonical links?

          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
          • 379seo
            379seo @Dr-Pete last edited by

            Thanks.  And since we've now implemented the aforementioned changes, I can give some findings back.

            What we did: We changed our sitemap to point to the same canonical URLs as are referenced in the tags on our product pages (only one entry in sitemap per product).

            What we didn't do: We didn't change the product pages themselves.  They still have a canonical URL link reference, pointing to a URL with no category paths, which does not naturally occur in the navigation of the site (on the site, product pages all have category paths in the URL).

            Findings: After submitting the new sitemap, the stats in Google Webmasters Tools indicate that almost all (> 96%) of our product pages are indexed.  We believe that the pages were already indexed (for the most part) and now the sitemap is useful for metrics.  From the timing, it's unlikely that the sitemap itself caused our index stats to get significantly better in just 1 day.  Possible, but unlikely.  In either case, since our product page URLs still reference canonical links which don't exist in the site's navigation, the evidence suggests that the canonical link itself is enough, and an actual navigation path to the canonical version of the page is not needed.  That's just empirical evidence, we have no inside info on Google's methods, but this is what we believe now after monitoring.

            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
            • Dr-Pete
              Dr-Pete Staff @379seo last edited by

              With the canonical tag in place, I'm guessing that extra link would basically be ignored. It's probably harmless, but I'm not sure it will do anything. You could create an HTML "sitemap" (or even an XML sitemap) with the canonical URLs. It's not my first choice, but it at least would give Google an extra push.

              379seo 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
              • 379seo
                379seo last edited by

                We're in process of updating our canonical tagging and our sitemap, based on the feedback here.  I have a question for the group though.  Unfortunately we can't follow Andy Smith's suggestion of creating a "By Brand" navigation section on the site, since this web site is all private label (they sell all products under their own brand name).

                One possible solution is to create a user-accessible site map page, with an "all products" paginated section, where all these product page URLs would be the canonical version.

                But another possible solution, easier to implement, would be to have a user accessible link on each product page to the canonical version of itself.  That is, when the user is on www.example.com/clothes/skirts/skater-skirt-12345, there would be a link to www.example.com/skater-skirt-12345, which would also be the URL specified in the canonical tag.

                This seems redundant, but our results so far have borne out that the canonical tag pointing to a URL which doesn't really exist anywhere in the navigation doesn't seem to be having the desired effect.  So, the thought is that a combination of the canonical tag, plus a "real" link to that same URL referenced in the canonical tag would better inform the search engine robots.  But our hesitation is whether it should work for this link to be on the product page itself (e.g. the non-canonical version).

                Any thoughts or feedback on approach?

                Dr-Pete 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                • 379seo
                  379seo last edited by

                  Thanks for the responses.  I've been monitoring for the past couple of weeks with the current sitemap and canonical structure, and so far the data seems consistent with the replies to this thread.  In GWT, the sitemap stats show less than 1% of the URLs submitted are indexed so far.  We have an action plan now to update the canonical structure and the sitemap to point to URLs which will be naturally crawled on the site as well.

                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                  • Dr-Pete
                    Dr-Pete Staff last edited by

                    There's no "have to" in most of these situations, but it boils down to this - the more canonical your canonical URL actually is, the better chance you have of Google honoring it. In other words, if you set a canonical tag but then never use that in internal links or your XML sitemap, odds are pretty good that Google may ignore the tag in some cases. You're basically saying "Hey, this URL is canonical! No, this one is! No, this one!" - it's a mixed message, and they're going to try to interpret it algorithmically.

                    I definitely think pointing to yet another version in the XML sitemap is a problem. Ideally, it would be great to unify your URLs, but if that's not possible, getting the canonical version in the sitemap would be a big help (and introducing yet another variant isn't good, so you'd kill two birds with one stone). As Andy said, if you could create some kind of internal link to the canonical version, even if it's not the main link, that could also help. I only hesitate on that one, because you don't want to end up with a weird, artificial linking structure (just creating links to have links).

                    Please note, this isn't necessarily a disaster the way you have it. Google could honor the tags properly and generally rank your site correctly. In my experience, though, it's a recipe for long-term problems, and it's worth fixing.

                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                    • Creode
                      Creode last edited by

                      The purpose of the canonical tag is to tell Google which page to index first. So, on that note, I usually use the canonical tag on the strongest page in terms of pagerank, as this shows which page is linked to the best.

                      I'm also guessing you're using a framwork/platform like Magento, this can make linking quite difficult. I often suggest creating Brand pages, and link to the product page, the "3rd URL", from there. Brand pages also great for SEO, as most people search for brands first. Great place to get some fat head keywords in.

                      Also, make sure you put in the http:// as well, I think it is good practice to put in the full URL.

                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                      • 1 / 1
                      • First post
                        Last post

                      Browse Questions

                      Explore more categories

                      • Moz Tools

                        Chat with the community about the Moz tools.

                      • SEO Tactics

                        Discuss the SEO process with fellow marketers

                      • Community

                        Discuss industry events, jobs, and news!

                      • Digital Marketing

                        Chat about tactics outside of SEO

                      • Research & Trends

                        Dive into research and trends in the search industry.

                      • Support

                        Connect on product support and feature requests.

                      • See all categories

                      Related Questions

                      • Jonathan.Smith

                        Should I include URLs that are 301'd or only include 200 status URLs in my sitemap.xml?

                        I'm not sure if I should be including old URLs (content) that are being redirected (301) to new URLs (content) in my sitemap.xml. Does anyone know if it is best to include or leave out 301ed URLs in a xml sitemap?

                        Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Jonathan.Smith
                        0
                      • Choice

                        Does a non-canonical URL pass link juice?

                        Our site received a great link from URL A, which was syndicated to URL B. But URL B is canonicalized to URL A. Does the link on URL B pass juice to my site? (See image below for a visual representation of my question) zgbzqBy

                        Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Choice
                        1
                      • McTaggart

                        Are these URL hashtags an SEO issue?

                        Hi guys - I'm looking at a website which uses hashtags to reveal the relevant content So there's page intro text which stays the same... then you can click a button and the text below that changes So this is www.blablabla.com/packages is the main page - and www.blablabla.com/packages#firstpackage reveals first package text on this page - www.blablabla.com/packages#secondpackage reveals second package text on this same page - and so on. What's the best way to deal with this? My understanding is the URLs after # will not be indexed very easily/atall by Google - what is best practice in this situation?

                        Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | McTaggart
                        0
                      • Seamoose

                        301 Redirection and apostrophes in URLs

                        Hi I am experiencing trouble getting any redirects with apostrophes in the URLs to 301 redirect in order to eliminate 404 errors. I have tried replacing the instance of the apostrophe in the source URL field to %27 and variations of this but to no avail. The site is a wordpress site (the old URLS are legacies from the old Business Catalyst site) and I am using the redirection plug in. I have gone into some detail with a helpful soul here http://wordpress.org/support/topic/how-to-deal-with-apostrophes-in-source-url but unfortunately to no result. If anyone has any idea how to solve this puzzle I would be grateful for the help. Example: http://www.tesselaars.com/blog/Inside_Flowers/post/Online_Marketing_for_Florists_Part_1%E2%80%93_A_Website_You_Won%27t_Regret/

                        Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | Seamoose
                        0
                      • JohnPeters

                        Strange URLs, how do I fix this?

                        I've just check Majestic and have seen around 50 links coming from one of my other sites. The links all look like this: http://www.dwww.mysite.com
                        http://www.eee.mysite.com
                        http://www.w.mysite.com The site these links are coming from is a html site. Any ideas whats going on or a way to get rid of these urls? When I visit the strange URLs such as http://www.dwww.mysite.com, it shows the home page of http://www.mysite.com. Is there a way to redirect anything like this back to the home page?

                        Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | JohnPeters
                        0
                      • nicole.healthline

                        How important are sitemap errors?

                        If there aren't any crawling / indexing issues with your site, how important do thing sitemap errors are? Do you work to always fix all errors? I know here: http://www.seomoz.org/blog/bings-duane-forrester-on-webmaster-tools-metrics-and-sitemap-quality-thresholds Duane Forrester mentions that sites with many 302's 301's will be punished--does any one know Googe's take on this?

                        Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | nicole.healthline
                        0
                      • WEB-IRS

                        Include Cross Domain Canonical URL's in Sitemap - Yes or No?

                        I have several sites that have cross domain canonical tags setup on similar pages.  I am unsure if these pages that are canonicalized to a different domain should be included in the sitemap.  My first thought is no, because I should only include pages in the sitemap that I want indexed. On the other hand, if I include ALL pages on my site in the sitemap, once Google gets to a page that has a cross domain canonical tag, I'm assuming it will just note that and determine if the canonicalized page is the better version.  I have yet to see any errors in GWT about this.   I have seen errors where I included a 301 redirect in my sitemap file.  I suspect its ok, but to me, it seems that Google would rather not find these URL's in a sitemap, have to crawl them time and time again to determine if they are the best page, even though I'm indicating that this page has a similar page that I'd rather have indexed.

                        Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | WEB-IRS
                        0
                      • CareerBliss

                        Can a XML sitemap index point to other sitemaps indexes?

                        We have a massive site that is having some issue being fully crawled due to some of our site architecture and linking. Is it possible to have a XML sitemap index point to other sitemap indexes rather than standalone XML sitemaps? Has anyone done this successfully? Based upon the description here: http://sitemaps.org/protocol.php#index it seems like it should be possible. Thanks in advance for your help!

                        Intermediate & Advanced SEO | | CareerBliss
                        0

                      Get started with Moz Pro!

                      Unlock the power of advanced SEO tools and data-driven insights.

                      Start my free trial
                      Products
                      • Moz Pro
                      • Moz Local
                      • Moz API
                      • Moz Data
                      • STAT
                      • Product Updates
                      Moz Solutions
                      • SMB Solutions
                      • Agency Solutions
                      • Enterprise Solutions
                      • Digital Marketers
                      Free SEO Tools
                      • Domain Authority Checker
                      • Link Explorer
                      • Keyword Explorer
                      • Competitive Research
                      • Brand Authority Checker
                      • Local Citation Checker
                      • MozBar Extension
                      • MozCast
                      Resources
                      • Blog
                      • SEO Learning Center
                      • Help Hub
                      • Beginner's Guide to SEO
                      • How-to Guides
                      • Moz Academy
                      • API Docs
                      About Moz
                      • About
                      • Team
                      • Careers
                      • Contact
                      Why Moz
                      • Case Studies
                      • Testimonials
                      Get Involved
                      • Become an Affiliate
                      • MozCon
                      • Webinars
                      • Practical Marketer Series
                      • MozPod
                      Connect with us

                      Contact the Help team

                      Join our newsletter
                      Moz logo
                      © 2021 - 2025 SEOMoz, Inc., a Ziff Davis company. All rights reserved. Moz is a registered trademark of SEOMoz, Inc.
                      • Accessibility
                      • Terms of Use
                      • Privacy

                      Looks like your connection to Moz was lost, please wait while we try to reconnect.